Concept of Eden as an ideal garden in Milton’s Paradise Lost, Book-IV – Critical study
Q. Write a critical note on the concept of Eden as an ideal garden in Milton’s Paradise Lost, Book-IV.
Answer: Milton's portrayal of Eden as an ideal garden in Book IV of "Paradise Lost" is a concept that has generated much critical discussion. While some readers may view Eden as a perfect and idyllic place, a closer examination reveals several critical points of contention.
First and foremost, Milton's depiction of Eden as an ideal garden is heavily influenced by his own theological beliefs, particularly his interpretation of the biblical Genesis account. This means that the concept of Eden in "Paradise Lost" is deeply rooted in Christian orthodoxy, and this religious bias shapes how readers perceive it. As a result, those who do not share Milton's religious convictions may find it difficult to fully embrace the idea of Eden as an ideal garden.
Furthermore, even within the context of Christian theology, there are aspects of Eden that can be seen as problematic. For instance, the idea of an ideal garden, where everything is perfect and humans live in harmony with nature and God, raises questions about the nature of free will and the human condition. If Eden is truly ideal, then why do Adam and Eve ultimately fall from grace? This raises questions about the inherent flaws in human nature and the limitations of an idealized environment.
Additionally, the concept of Eden as an ideal garden can be critiqued from an environmental perspective. While it may seem like a paradise, the garden in "Paradise Lost" is also characterized by a degree of stagnation and lack of diversity. It is a closed ecosystem, with no change or development, and this can be seen as limiting and unnatural. In the real world, ecosystems thrive on diversity and change, and an unchanging, idealized garden may not be sustainable in the long run.
Moreover, the very notion of an ideal garden can be seen as inherently exclusionary. In "Paradise Lost," Eden is reserved for Adam and Eve, and all other creatures are subservient to them. This hierarchical view of nature and humanity's dominion over it has been criticized for its anthropocentrism and its potential to justify the exploitation of the natural world.
In conclusion, while Milton's portrayal of Eden as an ideal garden in "Paradise Lost" may resonate with some readers, it is a concept that invites critical scrutiny. Its theological bias, its treatment of human nature, its environmental implications, and its hierarchical view of the natural world all raise valid concerns and offer fertile ground for critical analysis. Ultimately, the concept of Eden in Milton's epic poem is a complex and multifaceted one that invites readers to engage with its nuances and contradictions.
*****
Read also: 🔎
👉 Prologue to the Canterbury Tales : Chaucer's portrayal of 14th century England
👉 Sonnet 147 : Shakespeare’s view or literary context
👉 Sonnet No. 65 by William Shakespeare - Central idea and Summary
👉 Sonnet No. 116 (William Shakespeare) - definition of 'Love'
👉 Thomas Kyd’s ‘The Spanish Tragedy’ as a revenge play
👉 The Faerie Queene - the portrayal of Good vs. Evil
👉 The Flea by John Donne as a metaphysical poem